Since I don't play that style of music I don't really know what sounds good and what doesn't, so I don't have a useful perspective on your examples. I did look at the page for the Putney one but his samples don't include the JCM800 you used.
https://www.stltones.com/products/will-…r-kemper-bundle
Because I'm not a metal guy, none of the tones on his sample page sound "good" to me, but again that's more about them not being dialed in for the style of music I play rather than an assessment of quality.
Even then, you're running EMG pickups and I didn't see any mention of them on the spec sheet for Putney. I don't have any experience doing profiles myself but from what I understand, if you do a profile with a Tele and then play it with a high gain humbucker (to use an extreme) you're probably not going to be wild about how the humbucker sounds. I've never played EMGs so I don't know how different a critter they are.
What I do know is that, for instance, a Tele is so bright it can easily take your head off, so on a tube amp I might dial the treble down significantly. If I then profile that, it's the sound of an amp with the treble dialed down. Plug in a Les Paul, and the results may sound dull. Opposite of what you're experiencing but I wonder if that sort of thing is a factor.
Maybe if you did some recordings using the same profiles that these guys have on their websites for samples we could get a better feel for a/b - in a perfect world, using a guitar / pickup combination similar to their samples.
Display More
I'm fully aware that different guitars, pickups, monitors, even cables will have an effect on how the profile translates through ones equipment. I usually dial in the tone to my liking to suit my gear, but keep getting a rather noisy signal even if I lower the gain a tiny tad or if I up the "master" noise gate or set a noise stomp. I've tried different power outlets and even a furman power conditioner to no vail.
I have made a recording with 3 different guitars now, with three samples per guitar and profile. From what I can tell listening via both monitors and headphones is that the recording sounds slightly better when played back compared to how it sounds when recording, only through my headphones though, not the monitors for some reason.
I couldn't find any "guitar only" samples on any of the profiles I have, but the one with Dan Sugerman is the closest I can come to hearing the actual profile without all too much stuff happening, see the link below;
https://tonecratevault.com/collections/si…e-kemper-bundle
Here is the recording I made, sorry for the sloppy playing but I'm recovering from a MTB-accident a few months back where I hurt both my wrists;
https://www.dropbox.com/s/fzl4dgncwdrz…uitars.wav?dl=0
First 3 samples are with my EC-1000 (EMG 81 & EMG 60 humbuckers).
Next 3 samples is my Gibson Studio 2018 (490R and 498T humbuckers).
Last 3 samples is with my S7G Ola Englund Signature ( Bare Knuckle Aftermath humbuckers).
(Following the same order as Dan in the video, using the uberschall -> powerball -> 5153-profile for 3 riffs with each guitar then changing guitar.)
A friend of mine came along with his new PRS MT15 and that sounded -totally- different from all the different profiles I have of that specific amp, even with various DI profiles of it hooked directly to my PPC212CB, tried it with both a SD powerstage 170 and my Mooer baby bomb.
I guess something must be off if a 545 € amp blows my kemper away sound-wise when I have profiles of amps that sound stellar in comparsion with the MT15.